Comey and James search case dismissal : NPR

ALEXANDRIA, Va. — Attorneys for former FBI Director James Comey and New York Lawyer Common Letitia James requested a decide Thursday to dismiss the circumstances in opposition to them, saying the prosecutor who secured the indictments was illegally put in within the position.

U.S. District Choose Cameron McGowan Currie mentioned she expects to determine by Thanksgiving on challenges to Lindsey Halligan’s appointment as interim U.S. lawyer for the Jap District of Virginia. That call might assist decide the destiny of the politically charged circumstances, which had been each shepherded by the rapidly put in Halligan and collectively have amplified considerations that the Justice Division is getting used as a weapon to focus on President Donald Trump’s perceived adversaries.

Halligan was put in within the job at Trump’s urging by Lawyer Common Pam Bondi in September, simply days earlier than Comey was indicted, in what protection attorneys say was an end-run across the constitutional and statutory guidelines governing the appointment of U.S. attorneys. They are saying the maneuver was designed to make sure indictments in opposition to the president’s political opponents after the prosecutor who had been overseeing the 2 investigations, however had not introduced costs, was successfully pressured out.

“Ms. Halligan was the only prosecutor within the grand jury room, and when the only prosecutor lacks the authority,” mentioned Ephraim McDowell, certainly one of Comey’s protection attorneys, “that is not going to be a innocent error.”

U.S. attorneys, high federal prosecutors who oversee regional Justice Division outposts throughout the nation, are sometimes nominated by the president after which confirmed by the Senate. Attorneys common do have the authority to call an interim U.S. lawyer who can serve for 120 days, however attorneys for Comey and James argued that after that interval expires, the regulation provides federal judges the unique say of who will get to fill the emptiness.

The interim US lawyer resigned below stress

After then-interim U.S. lawyer Erik Siebert resigned in September whereas dealing with Trump administration stress to carry costs in opposition to Comey and James, Bondi put in Halligan, a White Home aide with no prior prosecutorial expertise. The appointment adopted a Trump submit on Reality Social by which he complained to Bondi concerning the lack of prosecutorial motion in opposition to his political enemies and mentioned, “JUSTICE MUST BE SERVED, NOW!!!”

Siebert had been appointed by Bondi in January to function interim U.S. lawyer. Trump in Might introduced his intention to appoint him, and judges within the Jap District unanimously agreed after his 120-day interval expired that he ought to be retained within the position.

Former FBI Director James Comey’s lawyer Abbe Lowell talks to reporters as he leaves the federal courthouse in Alexandria, Va., Thursday, Nov. 13, 2025.

Jose Luis Magana/AP

disguise caption

toggle caption

Jose Luis Magana/AP

However after the Trump administration successfully pushed him out in September, the Justice Division once more opted to make an interim appointment rather than the courts, one thing protection attorneys say it was not empowered below the regulation to do.

“If the federal government had been to prevail right here,” McDowell mentioned, then it “would by no means have to undergo Senate affirmation once more for U.S. attorneys.” He mentioned any dismissal of the indictment should be everlasting, with no alternative to carry the case once more, to keep away from rewarding the federal government for a violation.

The Justice Division defends Halligan’s appointment

The Justice Division maintains that the regulation doesn’t explicitly prohibit successive appointments of interim U.S. attorneys by the lawyer common. Henry Whitaker, a lawyer for the division, argued that the indictment was correctly returned by a grand jury and shouldn’t be dismissed over what he described as at most a paperwork or clerical error.

“The grand jury decided based mostly on the details and the regulation, and so they adopted their oath,” Whitaker mentioned.

He additionally mentioned that even when there have been questions on Halligan’s appointment, they had been resolved by the truth that Bondi had personally ratified the indictment and reviewed the grand jury proceedings. However Currie, the decide, questioned whether or not that was potential given {that a} part of the grand jury proceedings that had been produced to her was, for unexplained causes, lacking a bit.

A Justice Division spokesperson later mentioned that there was no lacking time and that the time interval in query considerations when the grand jury was deliberating, which “wouldn’t be included in a transcription.”

Comey has pleaded not responsible to costs of creating a false assertion and obstructing Congress, and James, a Democrat, has pleaded not responsible to mortgage fraud allegations. The challenges to Halligan’s appointment are a part of a multiprong effort to get the prosecutions tossed earlier than trial. Their attorneys have individually argued that the prosecutions are improperly vindictive and motivated by the president’s private animus towards their purchasers and will subsequently be dismissed.

Trump’s historical past with Comey and James

Comey, as FBI director within the early months of Trump’s first time period, infuriated the president by means of his oversight of an investigation into potential ties between Russia and Trump’s 2016 marketing campaign. Trump fired Comey in Might 2017. The 2 have been open adversaries since, with Comey labeling Trump “unethical” and evaluating him to a Mafia boss and Trump branding Comey an “untruthful slime ball” and calling for him to be punished due to the Russia investigation.

James has been a frequent goal of Trump’s ire, particularly since she gained a staggering judgment in opposition to him and the Trump Group in a lawsuit alleging he defrauded banks by overstating the worth of his actual property holdings on monetary statements. An appeals courtroom overturned the wonderful, which had ballooned to greater than $500 million with curiosity, however upheld a decrease courtroom’s discovering that Trump had dedicated fraud.