Are You My First? sparked a number of romantic connections between the virgin contestants — however which {couples} are nonetheless relationship and who has damaged up?
Hosted by Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe, Are You My First?, which premiered in August 2025, launched a brand new relationship experiment the place virgins navigated love, lust and shedding it. Viewers noticed a gaggle of hopeful contestants exploring connections, pairing up and even eliminating one another in what the present known as “virgin sacrifices.”
The season 1 finale led to two {couples} solidifying their romance — however no swiping of V-cards.
“We actually pushed them out of their consolation zones,” Kaitlyn mentioned on the present earlier than Colton joked, “We have now performed every part besides information it in at this level.”
Kaitlyn then requested in the event that they failed “as a result of nobody had intercourse” on the present. Colton replied by noting that they might nonetheless make that occur in a doable second season.
The hosts later stood by their method, with Colton telling Us after the present premiered, “The objective of the present was by no means to get them laid, I keep in mind joking about that on my Bachelor season like, ‘That isn’t the objective of the present.’ The objective is to attach with any person, to expertise these items. And folks skilled their firsts on Are You My First? in numerous methods.”
He continued: “On a deeper degree, I believe a number of the forged skilled the primary self-love and self-acceptance, like, having that deeper understanding of their virginity was the objective of this. And I want to assume after a variety of them have misplaced their virginity, they usually may need had these instruments to do this from the expertise.”
Scroll down to seek out out whether or not your favourite Are You My First? couple remains to be collectively:
Michael and Rachael
Michael and Rachael rapidly shaped a connection on season 1, however their journey was briefly paused when he needed to go away early as a result of a household emergency. When Michael returned,the pair instantly rekindled their romance.
In the course of the finale, Rachael felt overwhelmed by the potential of a future with Michael however they in the end left the present collectively. Rachael later revealed throughout a September 2025 interview on present host Kaitlyn’s “Off the Vine” podcast that she and Michael break up almost per week after leaving the tropical villa. Rachael has since “blocked” Michael’s telephone quantity and has not been in contact.
Layne and Brooklyn
Brooklyn explored her chemistry with just a few of the contestants earlier than Layne arrived and caught her eye. In the course of the finale, Layne obtained down on one knee and requested Brooklyn to be his girlfriend. with a promise ring. Nonetheless, they went their separate methods when the present ended.
“The primary time we noticed one another in actual life, he broke up with me,” Brooklyn claimed in a September 2025 TikTok video. “I used to be, clearly, fully shocked. … He mentioned one thing alongside the strains of, ‘[I’m] attempting to see if he ever felt a spark for me.’”
Jake and Sara
Viewers watched Jake and Sara navigate ups and downs all through season 1 whereas testing out their chemistry. From awkward kisses to unclear boundaries, Sara wasn’t positive how lengthy her relationship with Jake would final. The finale in the end ended with Sara shutting down Jake’s proposal to be boyfriend and girlfriend.
Whereas she known as him controlling on the present, Jake and Sara look like on good phrases — or a minimum of they observe one another on Instagram.
Mike and Carissa
The previous Bachelorette contestant pursued a reference to Carissa as quickly as he entered the present. Mike and Carissa’s romance was lower quick, nevertheless, when she was voted off. He subsequently left early after not with the ability to kind a bond with anybody else.
Mike and Carissa are presently mutuals on social media.
