Vibe coding for newbies: ChatGPT vs Claude vs Grok

The rise of vibe coding relies on the promise of providers like GPT-5: that sooner or later, you gained’t should know the right way to program in any respect with the intention to “create” software program — you’ll simply must know the right way to talk your software program concepts in plain outdated English. The AI will do all of the programming and debugging for you.

The final word objective: “software program on demand,” or any form of app, web site, or visualization you possibly can dream up, everytime you need it. However how shut are we? In the event you’re completely new to coding and don’t need to discover ways to code your self, must you count on to get one thing usable? I got down to strive a number of the greater client AI providers to see how they carry out. Briefly, I am searching for one of the best vibe coding instruments for newbies, no more superior instruments like Cursor or Windsurf.

For these assessments, I used GPT-5, Claude 4.1 Opus, and Grok 4 (Knowledgeable). 

How I examined vibe coding

To see how properly every of the totally different AI providers carried out when it got here to coding, I requested every service to create a web-based sport, a web-based productiveness service, and an iOS app.

Similar to once I examined one of the best AI picture mills, I used the identical prompts to check every mannequin. Listed here are the vibe coding prompts I used:

• Make a 2D browser sport the place you management a spaceship with the arrow keys and shoot lasers with the spacebar. Asteroids ought to spawn randomly and drift throughout the display screen. If a laser hits an asteroid, it explodes and your rating goes up. If the spaceship hits an asteroid, the sport ends and exhibits the ultimate rating. 

• Make a web-based to-do app that lets me add issues to my record, view objects as a listing or in a calendar, and lets me add data like a time it must be accomplished (not only a date). Additionally, add a random quote generator that exhibits a distinct random inspirational quote every time I press a button.

• Create a whole iOS app for monitoring private health objectives, the place customers can log each day exercises and look at progress charts. The app ought to embrace a house display screen displaying a listing of logged exercises with particulars like date, sort, period, and energy burned, plus choices so as to add new entries, edit or delete present ones, and search or filter by date or exercise sort.

My prompts take a look at totally different sorts of software program and providers, in addition to totally different sorts of knowledge. The AI might want to construct some form of physics framework for the sport, for instance, and both discover a pre-set record of quotes, or name an API to search out quotes, within the productiveness app.

I’m actually no skilled coder. I do have some primary web-development information and may discover my method round HTML and CSS information simply fantastic, however that’s about the place my expertise in programming ends. I actually gained’t be capable of assess how these providers carry out relating to code effectivity. I’m judging the tip product based mostly on how properly these providers observe my prompts. 

I’ve included hyperlinks to the sport and webpages these vibe coding instruments created, however I will not ask you to obtain the app. You may simply should take my phrase for it.

Vibe-coding a Net-based sport

See Play the outcomes:

All three providers had been capable of create a working internet sport, with barely totally different mechanics and extra touches. ChatGPT and Grok supplied a sport that included asteroids flying in from all instructions and the power to rotate the ship. Claude went for a Area Invaders-type set-up, with asteroids solely coming into from the highest of the display screen, and the ship pointed on the prime. 

Nonetheless, Claude’s strategy was the best-wanting. There have been shiny, retro colours, a background with stars, and a cool motion path behind the person. ChatGPT got here in shut second, and whereas there weren’t stars within the background or a way of motion, I preferred its minimalistic strategy, which highlighted explosions. Grok’s sport seemed the worst — and performed the worst — the design was boring and the asteroids had been simply grey circles.

Ultimately I most popular the general look of Claude’s sport, however the performance of ChatGPT’s. 

Winners: ChatGPT, Claude

Mashable Gentle Pace

Vibe-coding a Net-based app

See the outcomes:

All three providers had been capable of create a productiveness app that allowed the person to see the duties on a calendar, and to see inspirational quotes with the press of a button. The primary interface was related throughout all three of the providers, too. All of them opened to a listing view by default, providing fields to sort in a process and an possibility to pick a date and time for the duty.

Nevertheless, the apps differed tremendously in look. Grok was probably the most primary, as soon as once more. Its app seemed like a Phrase doc, with just a few buttons and fields to enter textual content. As soon as once more, ChatGPT was a big step up in look, however not as flashy as Claude. It gave the inspirational quote a distinct background shade, whereas Claude gave the entire interface a distinct shade and used emoji to spotlight instances and dates.

Variations in performance had been even larger. Grok’s app was mainly unusable; as soon as a process was created, there was no method to take away it or examine it off. Claude included a “delete” button subsequent to duties within the record view; clicking on a process within the calendar view generated a immediate asking in the event you wished to delete a process.

ChatGPT, nevertheless, was the most practical in key areas. Within the record view, it included a checkbox to mark a process as accomplished, together with a separate button to delete a process, and even a button to edit a process. It additionally included a “Notes” subject for every process, permitting customers so as to add extra than simply the duty title and its due date. All of which for a a lot better to-do record, even when it wasn’t the flashiest. 

Winner: ChatGPT

Vibe-coding an iOS app

This one was…a bit of more difficult.

Why? Nicely, Claude is the one service that truly generated a working iOS app. Each ChatGPT and Grok created apps that didn’t run in Apple’s Xcode. The app that Claude created ran fantastic.

That stated, Claude didn’t actually go the additional mile.

Claude’s app allowed me to enter exercises, then displayed them in a listing view, permitting me to filter based mostly on exercise sort, time they had been logged, and so forth. But it surely didn’t calculate energy burned for me (I needed to enter that data similar to I entered exercise sorts and the way lengthy I labored out for). And its “progress” chart was only a bar graph that confirmed what number of energy I burned throughout totally different exercise sorts. There was no method to create or view objectives.

To truly run an app in your iPhone that isn’t from the App Retailer, it’s a must to soar by some hoops. This isn’t one thing newbies can do in a minute or two; they’d be higher off sticking to web-based AI coding for now. 

Winner: Claude

The state of vibe coding

Two issues are clear. Firstly, AI providers are getting very good at serving to non-coders or newbie coders create apps, providers, and video games. Secondly, we can’t but dream up any piece of software program and count on an AI service to spit out a flawless, working product. I don’t assume we’re very far off, nevertheless.

App creation takes a bit of extra than simply producing a downloadable file. in the event you’re not fascinated by troubleshooting or studying any fundamentals, I’d steer clear from making an attempt to create precise iOS or Android apps. Net-only apps are preferable.

So what must you use to code in the event you’re a newbie? Nicely, if all you need to do is experiment with internet apps and little video games, each ChatGPT and Claude work properly. Excluding the app creation take a look at, ChatGPT carried out higher. OpenAI’s GPT-5, being free to all, is less complicated to entry than Claude Opus 4.1 — and for individuals who subscribe to every service’s respective $20-per-month plan, OpenAI imposes fewer limits. Nonetheless, don’t count on sub-par coding from Claude.

And to be honest to Grok, you’ll nonetheless probably get working web sites in the event you use it — they’ll simply be primary, boring, and should not stick as carefully to your prompts. As with Grok Think about, xAI has a protracted method to go to meet up with its rivals.

---

Disclosure: Ziff Davis, Mashable’s dad or mum firm, in April filed a lawsuit in opposition to OpenAI, alleging it infringed Ziff Davis copyrights in coaching and working its AI methods.