The jury in Sean “Diddy” Combs‘ intercourse trafficking case in New York shared considerations about a person juror with the choose not lengthy after they began deliberating Monday.
After greater than two hours of authorized directions from federal Decide Arun Subramanian, the jury of eight males and 4 girls headed behind closed doorways to deliberate at round 11:30 a.m. Subramanian advised the 5 alternate jurors to stay on standby in case they’re wanted to fill in on the primary jury who’re weighing fees that might put the hip-hop mogul in jail for all times.
About 10 minutes into deliberations, the jury despatched a word indicating they’d accomplished their first order of enterprise: electing a foreperson.
Lower than two hours later, at about 1:25 p.m., a word from the jury was learn in courtroom to tell the choose of considerations concerning one juror’s capacity to observe the directions. The jury requested the choose to query this juror. The choose mentioned the response with the prosecution and protection and determined to remind the jury of their obligation to observe the regulation and resume their deliberations.
After the choose initially proposed asking the jury foreperson the character of considerations in regards to the fellow juror, protection lawyer Marc Agnifilo urged warning and that much less be stated somewhat than extra.
“We are able to all the time ratchet it up. We will not ratchet it down,” Agnifilo stated.
Jurors are being supplied with a laptop computer loaded with the entire reveals proven in courtroom, together with textual content messages, pictures and movies of the sexual encounters on the coronary heart of the case.
Subramanian had pressured to the jury the significance of delivering a unanimous verdict, but in addition stated no juror ought to give up their beliefs with a purpose to attain unanimity.
Forward of the deliberations, CBS Information authorized contributor Caroline Polisi, a prison protection legal professional, mentioned on “CBS Mornings” what judges sometimes inform juries.
“The choose will instruct the jurors, ‘preserve your personal integrity with respect to what you imagine, however preserve an open thoughts, have interaction in discussions with different jurors, take a look at the proof, see different individuals’s perspective, and when you can with integrity actually come over to, you understand, the opposite aspect, then you may get to unanimity,'” Polisi stated.
Because the deliberations received underway, Combs confronted his household and supporters within the courtroom gallery. They bowed their heads in prayer — his relations holding fingers with one another. Once they completed, all of them applauded.
The jury will sift by means of seven weeks of typically graphic and emotional testimony in regards to the rap, style and actuality TV impresario’s propensity for violence and his sexual predilections, together with drug-fueled intercourse marathons dubbed “freak-offs” or “lodge nights.”
Combs, 55, has pleaded not responsible to federal fees of racketeering conspiracy, two counts of intercourse trafficking — relating to 2 of his ex-girlfriends — and two counts of transportation to have interaction in prostitution for allegedly arranging to fly intercourse employees throughout state traces.
Polisi stated the prosecution’s greatest probability at getting a conviction may very well be with the intercourse trafficking fees.
“The prosecution made clear there solely needs to be one occasion, out of those tons of of ‘freak-offs,’ one occasion the place it was coerced by drive, fraud or coercion, and that may embody threats of hurt that does not even embody bodily hurt,” Polisi stated. “So that may embody worry of economic hurt, worry of reputational hurt. Keep in mind, he videotaped all of those encounters, and the federal government laid out particular situations the place he threatened to launch these tapes.”
Shareif Ziyadat/Getty Photos
In closing arguments final week, federal prosecutors and Combs’ protection workforce took their final pictures at convincing jurors to convict or acquit the Grammy Award-winning founding father of Unhealthy Boy Data.
“The defendant used energy, violence and worry to get what he wished,” Assistant U.S. Legal professional Christy Slavik stated. “He thought that his fame, wealth and energy put him above the regulation.”
She stated that he used his “shut interior circle and a small military of non-public employees, who made it their mission to satisfy the defendant’s each need, promote his energy and shield his popularity in any respect prices.”
Agnifilo countered, “This is not about crime. It is about cash.” He famous that one in all Combs’ accusers within the prison case additionally sued him in civil courtroom.
“He’s not a racketeer. He’s not a conspirator to commit racketeering. He’s none of this stuff. He’s harmless. He sits there harmless. Return him to his household, who’ve been ready for him,” the lawyer advised jurors.
In all, 34 witnesses testified, headlined by Combs’ former girlfriends Cassie — the R&B singer born Casandra Ventura — and “Jane,” who testified beneath a pseudonym. Each girls stated he usually was violent towards them. Cassie stated he compelled her into tons of of sexual encounters with paid male intercourse employees whereas Jane recounted quite a few “lodge nights.”
Jurors additionally noticed now-infamous safety digicam video of Combs beating, kicking and dragging Cassie at a Los Angeles lodge in 2016 and clips from movies of sexual encounters.
Combs selected to not testify, and his attorneys did not name any witnesses of their protection case. His attorneys elected as an alternative to problem the accusers’ credibility throughout prolonged cross-examination questioning.
The protection has acknowledged that Combs veered into violence, however his attorneys preserve that the intercourse acts had been consensual. They contend that prosecutors are intruding in Combs’ private life and that he is executed nothing to warrant the costs towards him.
