Marc Maron, who wasn’t invited to carry out on the Riyadh Comedy Pageant, has spoken out in opposition to participation within the occasion, owing to Saudi Arabia’s appalling human rights report.
Amy Sussman/Getty Photos/Getty Photos North America
conceal caption
toggle caption
Amy Sussman/Getty Photos/Getty Photos North America
Saudi Arabia isn’t often called a middle for comedy. However by means of Oct. 9, the nation’s capital, Riyadh, is internet hosting dozens of A-list comedians — lots of them American — on the first ever Riyadh Comedy Pageant.
The participation of big-name funnymen, together with Dave Chappelle, Aziz Ansari, Kevin Hart and Jimmy Carr, has provoked criticism from fellow comedians, together with Marc Maron, Shane Gillis and Stavros Halkias, in addition to human rights teams and different commentators.
“The Saudi authorities is utilizing the Riyadh Comedy Pageant … to deflect consideration from its brutal repression of free speech and different pervasive human rights violations,” mentioned Human Rights Watch in a assertion this week. “Collaborating comedians, to keep away from contributing to laundering the Saudi authorities’s status, ought to use the comedy competition to publicly urge Saudi authorities to free unjustly detained Saudi dissidents, journalists, and human rights activists.”
A current U.S. State Division report on Saudi Arabia’s human rights report in 2024 listed abuses together with “arbitrary or illegal killings, disappearances, torture, arbitrary arrest and detention, and critical restrictions on freedom of expression and media freedom,” amongst different points.
Comedians’ spat
In a video on Maron’s Instagram channel, the WTF podcast host took intention at colleagues who signed as much as carry out on the competition, whereas referencing the allegations of the Saudi authorities’s potential involvement within the Sept. 11 assaults and its function within the 2018 homicide of journalist Jamal Khashoggi.
“From the oldsters that introduced you 9/11. Two weeks of laughter within the desert, do not miss it!'” joked Maron acerbically. “The identical man that is gonna pay them is similar man that paid that man to bone-saw Jamal Khashoggi and put him in a f***ing suitcase. However do not let that cease the yucks, it is gonna be an excellent time!”
Gillis and Halkias had been each invited to carry out at this occasion, which was introduced in July by Common Leisure Authority chairman Turki Alalshikh. On his podcast, Gillis mentioned he declined a “vital bag” to carry out on the occasion. “I took a principled stand,” he mentioned. In a podcast dialog with Chris DiStefano, Halkias mentioned “Cannot do it.”
Fellow comic DiStefano, conversely, advised Halkias he accepted the invitation: “I did not need to do it both,” he mentioned, including that it was his spouse who urged him to take the cash.
Saudi Arabia’s play
NPR reached out to representatives of almost each taking part comic for remark, in addition to the Saudi embassy in Washington, D.C., and the nation’s Common Leisure Authority. Nobody had responded by the point of publication. Nonetheless, in its assertion asserting the occasion, the Common Leisure Authority described the competition as “the most important of its sort globally,” including that it “displays the efforts to amplify Riyadh’s standing as a number one vacation spot for main cultural and inventive occasions.”
As a nation closely depending on oil, Saudi Arabia is presently engaged in a plan to diversify itself economically, socially and culturally. Its Imaginative and prescient 2030 program, carried out in 2016, encompasses efforts to extend the nation’s visibility on the cultural stage. “Imaginative and prescient 2030 is a blueprint that’s diversifying the financial system, empowering residents, making a vibrant surroundings for each native and worldwide traders, and establishing Saudi Arabia as a world chief,” the web site states.
A historical past of pushback
The Riyadh Comedy Pageant is not the primary time artists have impressed blowback for accepting invites to take part in occasions in Saudi Arabia.
Large title pop music acts together with Mariah Carey, The Black Eyed Peas and Justin Bieber all earned criticism for opting to carry out within the nation lately. “Does not she know Saudi Arabia is likely one of the most repressive and murderous regimes on the planet?” wrote the activism group Code Pink in a 2019 assertion calling for Carey to cancel her present that yr.
And American visible artists who’ve exhibited their work at Desert X AlUla, a derivative of the U.S. Desert X artwork competition within the Saudi Arabian desert, in addition to the occasion’s organizers, have additionally acquired criticism. In a 2019 article, Los Angeles Instances artwork critic Christopher Knight referred to as the present “morally corrupt.” Knight added: “Saudi Arabia is an absolute monarchy constructed on theocratic legislation. Free expression is forbidden. Unlawful. A felony act.”
Comic Tim Dillon mentioned on his podcast final month that he signed up for monetary causes. He mentioned he had been provided “a big sum of cash” — $375,000 for one efficiency — and mentioned that different comedians had been provided as a lot as $1.6 million. He advised his detractors to “recover from it,” including, “So what if they’ve slaves, they’re paying me sufficient to look the opposite method.”
However in an episode of the Tim Dillon Podcast final week, the comic introduced he’d been faraway from the lineup for the feedback he made in regards to the nation’s report on slavery. (NPR reached out to Saudi’s Common Leisure Authority for verification, however has not but heard again.) “I addressed it in a humorous method they usually fired me,” Dillon mentioned on his podcast. “I definitely wasn’t gonna present up in your nation and insult the individuals which might be paying me the cash.”
