Each automobile rental firm has a “don’t hire,” or DNR, listing containing the names of former prospects who’re now not allowed to hire automobiles with them.
The truth is, Hertz, Avis, Enterprise and others typically completely ban even top-tier elite members of their loyalty program in the event that they discover the circumstances warrant it.
I do know this firsthand as a result of, as a shopper advocate, banned automobile rental prospects have flooded my helpline for years. Most of those vacationers had no concept that a few of their actions might result in such extreme and embarrassing outcomes.
The outcast automobile rental prospects all need the identical factor once they contact me: to get off the DNR listing. They hope to make amends and get again on the street with their favourite automobile rental firms.
There’s sometimes excellent news for a few of these folks, however solely a small proportion.
In contrast to airways and cruise traces, which are inclined to ban problematic passengers for all times, automobile rental firms can typically be forgiving. Nonetheless, the trail off the DNR listing relies upon fully on how the traveler finally ends up on it within the first place.
Listed below are the real-life experiences of some automobile rental prospects who discovered themselves banned, why they had been positioned on the DNR listing, and what you are able to do to keep away from the identical destiny.
Violating the phrases of the automobile rental contract led to the DNR listing
A fast option to get banned from a automobile rental firm is by violating the phrases of your contract. Hertz President’s Circle member Sean O. lately discovered this out.
Hertz’s DNR listing was not the place Sean ever imagined his title would seem. As a touring insurance coverage adjuster who used Hertz completely, he assumed his valued buyer standing was safe.
Day by day E-newsletter
Reward your inbox with the TPG Day by day publication
Be a part of over 700,000 readers for breaking information, in-depth guides and unique offers from TPG’s consultants
And it was — till he prolonged his final rental automobile contract with out letting the company know.
“I used to be touring all through the state (Florida) serving to householders and companies impacted by the hurricane,” Sean recalled. “Many areas I used to be working in had spotty Wi-Fi and cell service due to the continuing storms. My authentic rental automobile contract was to finish on September 20.”
As usually occurs in Sean’s line of labor, the project took longer than was initially anticipated and he didn’t return the automobile on the agreed-upon date.
One complete week after Hertz anticipated Sean to return the automobile, he was nonetheless driving round in it.
“I had simply been so busy. However on September 27, I noticed I had by no means known as Hertz in regards to the extension,” Sean informed me. “I known as the President’s Circle line and informed the agent I might return the rental automobile the subsequent day.”
Sean says the agent thanked him for letting Hertz know and did not point out something was improper.
However the wheels had been already in movement for Sean’s journey to the DNR listing.
‘Your renting privileges have been completely suspended’
Automotive rental firms take it very critically when a buyer doesn’t return a automobile as scheduled. Ignoring the top date in your contract and being unresponsive to outreach by staff making an attempt to find the automobile is usually an categorical lane to the DNR listing.
After Sean did not return his rental automobile on time, the native department started calling him. Hertz continued to try to succeed in him all through the week, however Sean says he didn’t obtain the messages.
By the point he known as the President’s Circle seven days later, Hertz had already blacklisted Sean’s account. The corporate needed to make sure he returned the automobile earlier than giving him the stunning information.
The next day, he returned the overdue rental automobile, nonetheless unaware of his change in standing from darling buyer to Hertz outcast.
Every week after Sean returned the rental automobile, he acquired the next notification:
“That is to tell you that your rental and approved operator privileges, in addition to any membership in [loyalty] packages, have been completely suspended at Hertz, Greenback, Thrifty, and Firefly automobile rental since you failed to reply to automobile overdue notices, or have been unable to offer an excusable purpose for not returning a automobile, leading to having to repossess the overdue automobile.”
Sean spent the subsequent a number of weeks trying to persuade Hertz that he had an affordable clarification for not returning the automobile on time. He additionally identified that he had a sound bank card on file with no preset restrict and a historical past of typically overextending his rental due to the character of his work.
Sadly, all his pleas fell on unsympathetic ears — or, extra probably, they had been filtered by way of synthetic intelligence packages that don’t possess ears in any respect.
Months later, Sean was nonetheless on the DNR listing with no signal of Hertz altering its place.
Then Sean requested me if I might deliver his case to the manager group at Hertz for reconsideration.
Hertz agrees to take away this buyer from the DNR listing

Sadly, to the detriment of shoppers with points to resolve, many firms have automated their customer support facilities with synthetic intelligence packages. These techniques can not make case-by-case exemptions or gives, or forgive errors {that a} human agent may forgive.
I suspected Sean had been pleading his case to AI customer support bots.
However my govt contact at Hertz and her group are actual folks. I believed, given Sean’s line of labor and historical past with the corporate, they might probably discover Sean’s banned standing excessive. I despatched the small print of his case over to Hertz, and really rapidly, Sean acquired excellent news.
Hertz restored him to the President’s Circle and returned his factors, and he’s again within the firm’s good graces, with the understanding that sooner or later, he should not self-extend his contracts with out alerting Hertz forward of time.
The lesson right here is: Most automobile rental prospects who ignore the top date of their contract will find yourself on the DNR listing. Vacationers who can not return their automobile as scheduled should inform the corporate, clarify why and get an official approval for an extension.
Requesting an e mail affirmation of the change from the automobile rental firm can also be essential. You may want that proof in case you are renting from an company that studies overdue automobiles as stolen, which many do.
Vacationers ought to know that many automobile rental branches are franchised, too. Meaning they’re independently owned and operated. So, if one location lets you deviate out of your contract, it is best to by no means assume others will. That misunderstanding was the basis of Sean’s disagreeable expertise, since he had been in a position to self-extend leases from different branches with no points previously. However that nearly led to his everlasting placement on Hertz’s DNR listing.
Submitting a bank card dispute over cleansing charges
Submitting a bank card dispute over charges a automobile rental firm desires you to pay also can lead you straight to the DNR listing. Sadly, many shoppers have mistaken understandings about once they can file a dispute or chargeback, and what “profitable” one really means.
Monica V., a former Thrifty buyer, filed a bank card dispute after her final rental.
“After we returned the rental automobile, Thrifty notified me that it was charging me a $555 cleansing charge,” Monica informed me. “My fiance smokes, however he did not mild up within the automobile. We most likely smelled like smoke as a result of we went to a on line casino. However I should not should pay for that.”
The automobile rental firm didn’t agree with Monica’s reasoning. The group didn’t care why the automobile smelled like smoke, simply that it did scent like smoke when she returned it.
When Monica wrote to the corporate with a criticism, Thrifty reiterated that she was answerable for returning the rental automobile in the identical situation through which it had been given to her — with out the odor of cigarettes. The charge resulted from the necessity to take the automobile offline for a day to be deep-cleaned.
Earlier than delving additional into this case, let me simply acknowledge that, from the complaints I obtain every week, I do know that automobile rental cleansing charges are out of hand nowadays.
Some areas routinely cost prospects a whole lot of {dollars} to hoover mud, take away small quantities of trash and deep-clean vehicles unnecessarily. There isn’t any query that cleansing charges have turn into a profitable revenue stream for some company branches.
Monica agreed that the automobile smelled like smoke after her rental. Nonetheless, she was arguing that she shouldn’t should pay for a cleansing since nobody really smoked within the automobile.
When Thrifty disagreed, she disputed the cost together with her bank card firm. She gained the case by default as a result of the automobile rental firm didn’t problem the chargeback.
Monica, like many shoppers, believed that the bank card firm’s resolution was last and that Thrifty was obligated to just accept it.
Nonetheless, she received a stunning lesson about what triumphing with a bank card dispute really means for shoppers.
Profitable a bank card dispute doesn’t suggest what you suppose

Just a few weeks after her chargeback was processed, Monica was shocked when she acquired a DNR discover from Hertz, the dad or mum firm of Thrifty.
The message knowledgeable her that it had despatched the $555 debt to collections. Now, her credit standing was in danger.
When she contacted me to ask for help, she was satisfied that her bank card firm’s resolution was binding.
“This isn’t solely an invalid cost (nobody smoked within the rental automobile) however has additionally price me appreciable time, stress, and inconvenience. After disputing the fees with my bank card firm (and profitable), I’m on the ‘Do Not Hire’ listing. They [Hertz] additionally despatched me to collections. I journey usually, which has induced main challenges when reserving a automobile. I’m the only breadwinner of my household, and cash is tight. Are you able to assist me get off this listing?”
Monica shouldn’t be alone in her perception that efficiently disputing a bank card cost closes the dispute completely with no repercussions. In actuality, it solely definitively ends the involvement of the bank card firm. For a lot of shoppers, the end result of a bank card dispute solely ushers in a brand new chapter within the battle.
Automotive rental firms not often reply to bank card disputes. If a service provider does reply to a chargeback criticism inside 20 to 45 days (relying on the bank card), the client wins by default.
However, one essential element about bank card disputes that the majority shoppers I converse to do not know is that the end result shouldn’t be legally binding. When a shopper wins a bank card dispute, the service provider can pursue the debt in different methods, and automobile rental firms almost all the time do, relegating the purchasers to the DNR listing and sending the unpaid cost to a collections company.
As a result of Monica seemingly acknowledged the automobile smelled like smoke, she owed the charge. I agreed that it was fairly excessive in comparison with typical automobile rental cleansing expenses that normally vary from $250 to $450. Had she contacted me earlier than the bank card dispute, I’m assured that I might have mediated a discount within the charge. However after I acquired her criticism, it was too late. I knew the one manner off the DNR listing can be for her to repay the $555.
That was one thing she was not keen to do, although, and the final time I heard from Monica, she remained on Thrifty’s DNR listing.
Generally, automobile rental firms cost unfair charges and invoice for damages the client didn’t trigger. Nonetheless, in nearly all instances, a bank card dispute shouldn’t be the correct option to resolve the issue.
Customers ought to solely provoke a bank card dispute as a final resort as a result of there are critical flaws within the scope and safety of the bank card dispute course of.
It’s all the time greatest to make use of the official channels on the rental firm to attempt to resolve a criticism. When you want a dependable title and phone data for an actual individual at a automobile rental firm who might help you, ship your request to my group, Shopper Rescue, and we will present that to you freed from cost.
Making threats and behaving badly
Did you ever sidle as much as the automobile rental counter, desperate to be in your manner, and uncover there was not a automobile ready for you? Or possibly you discover a massively lengthy line forward of you when you find yourself working on fumes.
Irritating eventualities like these are widespread occurrences at automobile rental businesses worldwide. Nonetheless, prospects ought to know that in the event that they take out their frustration on staff, it may possibly have long-term penalties.
Gordon M., a former Hertz President’s Circle member, discovered this out after he confirmed up on the rental counter and an worker questioned the company low cost code he was utilizing. After an extended day of journey and up to date issues with different Hertz areas, the request despatched Gordon over the sting.
He started insulting the agent, a feminine worker working alone at that location.
“She requested me for proof of my affiliation with the enterprise that I based. It was not my most interesting hour. I wholeheartedly apologize for letting my frustrations from earlier rental experiences with Hertz have an effect on my dealings with this agent. I might need raised my voice an octave or two, however I used to be nowhere close to shouting.”
Nonetheless, the loudness of his voice was not what the worker discovered threatening. In Gordon’s personal phrases, which he repeated in a follow-up letter to the corporate, he known as Hertz (and the agent in entrance of him) “A bunch of scumbags” and informed the employee that he can be reporting her.
The agent knowledgeable Gordon that he would want to attend for a supervisor to reach since she wouldn’t proceed working with him. He sat down to attend, received on the telephone with Hertz customer support and continued his rant.
When the supervisor arrived, Gordon assumed it was to defuse the scenario and make issues proper for him.
He was improper. The situation supervisor was there to not appease Gordon however to guard the agent.
“He informed me that Hertz had canceled my reservation and I ought to go away,” Gordon recalled. “I used to be livid, however I left and went to Sixt to hire a automobile. I even have a company account there.”
A lot to his shock, when he arrived on the Sixt counter, the agent informed him the corporate couldn’t hire him a automobile.
Just a few days after this incident, Gordon tried to hire a automobile at one other Hertz location with out interacting with a counter agent. He discovered his title on the President’s Circle show board, went to the lot, chosen a automobile, and drove away.
However he didn’t get far.
When he received to the gate, an attendant knowledgeable him that he was banned from Hertz. Gordon was unceremoniously instructed to go away the automobile and go elsewhere. Embarrassed, he gathered his issues and made the stroll of disgrace out of the lot.
It was a far fall from the President’s Circle to the blacklist.
By the point Gordon reached out to me together with his story, he was nonetheless unclear of his destiny with Sixt, however he hoped to get again within the good graces of each firms.
Sadly for Gordon, it’s uncommon for any firm to take a buyer off the DNR listing in the event that they had been positioned on it due to threatening or aggressive conduct towards staff.
Since I have no idea Gordon personally, I couldn’t vouch for him and I had no foundation to ask Hertz to carry the ban.
Automotive rental businesses, similar to some other firm, are free to refuse service to problematic prospects. I really useful he decide a brand new favourite automobile rental firm and to be conscientious about his conduct sooner or later.
He nonetheless needed me to share his expertise, although.
“I would really like your readers to know that there isn’t a due course of with these automobile rental firms. It was my phrase in opposition to the agent that day since nobody else was there. However I received banned. I additionally suppose it is outrageous that they shared my data with Sixt.”
As Gordon’s scenario demonstrates, regardless of the place your travels take you or what challenges you encounter, by no means unload your frustrations on others. I’m all the time shocked by the variety of requests for assist I get from self-described “good” individuals who had been banished from an organization after taking out their anger on an worker.
Descending into face-to-face confrontations with frontline staff is aggressive and reveals a scarcity of self-control. And keep in mind, the individual on the receiving finish of such conflicts has no concept simply how far that anger might go. Earlier than confronting an worker about an issue, take a step again and picture how the scene may look by way of the lens of a 3rd occasion.
A few years of case information shared with me by shoppers and journey firms point out that automobile rental businesses, cruise traces, motels and airways are fed up with poorly behaved prospects. And rightly so. Fellow vacationers are additionally fed up with individuals who cannot preserve self-control in public. And when that occurs, you simply may end up on an organization’s banned listing.
Backside line
Getting banned from a automobile rental firm can result in a lifetime of inconvenience. That is very true should you stay in an space {that a} particular model primarily companies, or your house of employment has unique contracts with a single rental firm.
The excellent news is that it’s pretty simple to keep away from the DNR listing of your favourite automobile rental firm. Simply adhere to those easy pointers:
- Abide by your rental contract’s phrases.
- Don’t file bank card disputes over charges the corporate says you owe; attempt to resolve the matter straight with the rental firm.
- Keep cordial conduct even when confronted with irritating circumstances.
The dangerous information is that after an organization provides your title to the blacklist, it might keep there endlessly with no recourse.
In case you have an issue with a automobile rental firm, cruise line, airline, trip rental company, lodge or bank card firm, ship your request for assist to ombudsman@thepointsguy.com, and I will be joyful to attempt that will help you, too.