Your 2026 pay elevate might be a “peanut-butter”-style enhance, with new analysis from compensation professional Payscale discovering greater than 4 in 10 corporations are opting to offer an identical, across-the-board hikes quite than merit-based raises.
This yr, 44% of corporations plan to depend on the peanut-butter strategy — a technique of evenly spreading pay hikes throughout the workforce — in line with a brand new report from Payscale.
Some employers are transferring away from performance-based pay will increase due to issues that the follow is simply too subjective and doubtlessly biased, Payscale famous. Spreading pay hikes out evenly throughout a workforce can also be simpler from an administrative perspective, which may save corporations cash.
Pay hikes will maintain regular at 3.5% in 2026, unchanged from 2025, the group discovered. Nonetheless, merit-based pay hikes stay the predominant methodology utilized by corporations, with 48% of organizations saying they plan to depend on performance-based raises, Payscale mentioned.
There are downsides to peanut-butter raises, as they’ll discourage some staff from placing in additional effort if they do not anticipate they’re going to be rewarded for going the additional mile, Payscale mentioned.
“With no differentiation based mostly on efficiency, it is simpler to offer everybody one thing. However there’s a danger that high performers will really feel deprived in that atmosphere,” Ruth Thomas, chief compensation strategist at Payscale, instructed CBS Information.
She famous that corporations that eschew merit-based pay will increase can nonetheless reward high performers with bonuses or promotions, for instance.
“Base pay will not be your solely lever, and organizations could look extra at bonuses and promotions when base pay budgets are restricted,” she added.
Peanut-butter raises began gaining traction after the Nice Recession as budget-constrained corporations turned to the technique, Thomas mentioned. She added that extra corporations are as soon as once more tightening their budgets.
“We’re now seeing a sluggish decline in pay enhance budgets once more, so it is simpler to offer everybody a comparatively flat enhance,” Thomas mentioned.
Small firm, large elevate
Smaller institutions with fewer than 100 staff are providing increased pay will increase — 4% — in comparison with their bigger counterparts. Companies with between about 10,000 to 50,000 employees mentioned they plan handy out 3% raises in 2026, the report discovered.
“Smaller employers seem like utilizing pay extra aggressively to compete for expertise, whereas bigger organizations face structural and budgetary challenges that restrict flexibility,” the researchers mentioned within the report.
Common raises additionally fluctuate by business, with corporations in sectors struggling to seek out employees providing above-average pay hikes. For instance, these sectors are providing above-average pay will increase:
- Building — 5%
- Companies and consultancies — 4.5%
- Know-how — 4%
Some blue-collar fields, comparable to building, are newly in style amongst youthful job-seekers as AI seems poised to alter the hiring panorama and supplant coders and different white-collar jobs, whereas blue-collar roles are seen as extra proof against AI’s impression.
Some 77% of Era Z say they need a job that is laborious to automate, with many figuring out professions like carpenter, plumber and electrician as occupations they consider match the criterion, in line with a 2025 survey from Jobber.
