To the editor: I not often agree with contributing author Josh Hammer’s op-eds. That stated, I agree with him about cultural assimilation (“The true lesson of the Hanukkah story,” Dec. 19).
America is a tradition of immigrants bringing vestiges of their cultural origins with them as they reinvent themselves. No person already within the U.S. ought to attempt to make them cease celebrating these origins, utilizing their first languages or waving their homeland flags. They’ve an ideal proper to keep up their tradition.
In fact, residing of their new houses would require that they be taught in regards to the traditions, language and flag that had been created by those that got here earlier than. And they’re going to be taught, to better and lesser levels, as they really feel the necessity. These trying to bleach the tradition out of immigrants immediately are the modern model of the Seleucid Empire Hammer speaks of, which tried to power the Jews to assimilate within the Hanukkah story.
This vacation, because the op-ed factors out, is an ideal reminder for us all to have fun the particular variety of the U.S. and to watch how all of our variations make us stronger collectively.
David Gene Echt, Torrance
..
To the editor: Hammer says, “The Maccabees had nationwide and civilizational pleasure, and it was due to that pleasure that they fought so valiantly and refused to bend the knee to Hellenistic assimilation.”
The analogue of that assertion to our present instances and malaise couldn’t be clearer. Do we have now the nationwide and civilizational pleasure to struggle again in opposition to the destruction of our constitutional democracy, or are we now so weak and disinterested that we’ll undergo our personal demise?
It’s the query of the yr. Thanks, Hammer, for posing it so clearly.
William Noble, Santa Monica
